Alright, let’s tackle this head-on, because I know you’ve wondered about it—or at least overheard someone at the bar toss the question around like it’s a hot potato. Why do men often end up marrying women who are “average-looking” rather than those Instagram-model-level 8s, 9s, or 10s?
Buckle up, because your big brother has some thoughts. Plus, I did a little research to back this up (yes, science is involved), and I’ll throw in some personal insights to keep it real.
It’s Not Just About Looks—It’s Science
So, here’s what the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology has to say. In a study, men were asked to list what they prioritize most in a partner: physical attractiveness, earning potential, or personality traits. Shocker—most men initially chose physical attractiveness. Of course, they did. You see a gorgeous person walk into a room, and your brain goes, “Them. Right there.”
But here’s where it gets interesting. The study paired these men with their “ideal type” (basically, their dream girl) and had them engage in a conversation. Sounds like a fantasy setup, right? Nope. After talking with these women, most men started losing interest faster than my enthusiasm for kale smoothies.
Why? Because long-term compatibility isn’t about looks alone. When it comes to settling down, most men look for qualities that make them feel comfortable, empowered, and secure. Turns out, a flashy exterior doesn’t always guarantee that deeper connection.
The Fear Factor: Insecurity Plays a Role
Let’s get real for a second. Dating someone who turns heads wherever they go can feel like being on a reality TV show—constant drama, competition, and pressure. Psychotherapists say this boils down to insecurity.
I saw this play out with my buddy Chris. He dated this absolute knockout—think cover-model gorgeous. But every time they went out, he’d get in his head about other guys looking at her or trying to strike up conversations. By the end of their relationship, he wasn’t just jealous—he was exhausted.
Men tend to lean toward women who feel like a safer bet—someone they trust, someone who won’t leave them feeling like they’re in a never-ending game of Survivor: Relationship Edition.
The Evolutionary Edge
Here’s where our caveman ancestors come into the picture. Back in the day, survival was the name of the game. You didn’t just pick a partner because they looked good in animal skins—you picked someone who made you feel secure and capable of raising the next generation.
Even now, that instinct sticks around. Men aren’t just marrying “average-looking” women because it’s easier; they’re doing it because those women often bring something extra to the table. It’s not about the perfect waist-to-hip ratio—it’s about kindness, loyalty, and shared goals. And frankly, that’s a better foundation for a lifelong partnership than Instagram-worthy selfies.
Why Men End Up Loving Their Partners More
Here’s the kicker. Studies show men often end up loving the women they marry more deeply over time, regardless of whether they started as the “most attractive” option. Why? Because real love grows. It’s built on late-night talks, inside jokes, and the comfort of knowing your partner has your back—through bad hair days, job stresses, and everything in between.
The Truth Of Life
So, why do men marry “average-looking” women? Because they’re smart enough to realize that “average” is just a word. What society labels as “average” doesn’t matter when someone makes you laugh, supports your dreams, and knows how to whip up your favorite Sunday breakfast.
And honestly, if you’re still hung up on numbers—8s, 9s, 10s—you’re playing the wrong game. Life’s not a dating app. It’s about finding someone who makes you feel at home.
Take it from me: when you’re 70, sitting on the porch with your partner, you won’t care how symmetrical their face was back in the day. You’ll care about the stories you built together, the laughter you shared, and the life you created as a team.
So, there you have it. Men marry “average-looking” women because they know what really matters. Now, go forth and stop rating people like they’re Yelp reviews.
What do you think? Ever felt like you were overlooked because you didn’t fit some arbitrary standard? Let’s talk—I’m here to keep it real with you.
Leave a Reply